Posted by
John David Powell on Friday, August 14, 2009 9:25:19 AM
The hot and
miserable August weather has moved indoors in cities and towns across
our land. Moved indoors and taken the form of recriminating rhetoric as
neighbors square off in shout fests billed as informational town hall
meetings about health care.
Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid (D-Nev.) enjoys
using the term “evil mongers’ to describe American citizens expressing
their anxieties and frustrations, many times with verbal vigor and
abuse, over healthcare proposals they fear will adversely affect their
lives and the lives of their children and of their parents.
Reid, along with many
supporters of the various healthcare bills floating around Capitol
Hill, says Republican special interest groups have organized the
protests. That is the case to some degree. But to say individual
Americans who cut across generational, social, and economic lines
cannot think for themselves and cannot decide on their own to attend
these meetings is simply absurd and borders on the disingenuous.
These town hall
demonstrators, many of them children of the Summer of Love, have taken
a page out of the liberal playbook to create our current Summer of
Dissonance. Obstructive behavior to silence opposing views is not
uncommon, particularly on college campuses, and the targets are usually
conservative speakers.
In October 2006, someone pulled a fire alarm at Georgetown University
to stop a speech by Minuteman co-founder Chris Simcox. A few weeks
later, Columbia University students stormed a stage where Jim
Gilchrist, the other Minuteman co-founder, was speaking.
In October 2007, members of Amnesty International, Veterans for Peace,
and Students for Justice in Palestine, among others, disrupted a
lecture by David Horowitz at Emory University, a common occurrence for
Horowitz.
In April 2008, dozens of
lesbians at Smith College climbed through windows and stormed the
podium to stop a speech by Ryan Sorba, author of The Born Gay Hoax.
And last April, University of North Carolina police arrested six people
who disrupted a speech by Virgil Goode, a former congressman from
Virginia, who was speaking against affirmative action and illegal
immigration. A week earlier, UNC police used pepper spray on students
who disrupted a speech by Tom Tancredo, a former congressman from
Colorado, who was talking about his opposition to in-state tuition
benefits for illegal immigrants.
Back when I handled
communications for a university president, I crafted the school’s
position regarding controversial speech on campus. The result was a
statement that said universities, by their very nature, are forums for
the free expression, discussion, and debate of all views, including
those that may be unpopular or even repugnant to some members of the
university community or to the public. I went on to point out that we
should encourage these exchanges as long as they remain within the
boundaries of the law, which is an idea essential to a thriving and
open democracy and, if followed, would temper today’s tempestuous town
hall meetings.
I have come to believe over
the years that some people on the left of the political spectrum
interpret the First Amendment to mean this: “You can say what you like
as long as I like what you say.” This is why they meet challenges to
their political agenda with hateful words and ham-handed techniques.
These attempts to stifle questions and concerns end up frustrating
citizens not used to civil disobedience and unruly demonstrations.
They learn fast, however,
these so-called special-interest puppets and evil mongers. They learn
fast and respond to attempted censorship with shouts and jeers, chants
and slogans. They quickly become that which they do not like and do not
respect.
And this why we need Atticus Finch, the quiet and reasoning father in Harper Lee’s Pulitzer Prize winning novel To Kill A Mockingbird.
We need to sit on the porch and listen to Atticus explain how we
confuse issues and drown discourse with raised voices and angry fists.
He would begin by telling us
to hold our heads high and keep our fists down. “No matter what anyone
says to you, don't let 'em get your goat,” he would say, adding, “Try
fighting with your head for a change.”
Atticus would then raise his
chin and look out over those assembled around his porch, the very ones
who had been hurling invectives at each other and getting no closer to
resolving the issues. “You never really understand a person until you
consider things from his point of view,” he would say, “until you climb
into his skin and walk around in it.”
Finally, he would place his
hands on his knees, slowly stand, then look down upon the upturned
faces. He would watch the thoughtful in the crowd nod their heads and
walk away into the night. Then he would imperceptibly shake his head as
he looked at the remaining angry faces, and, in a quiet voice, almost
as if speaking to himself, he would say, “I think I'm beginning to
understand something. I think I'm beginning to understand why Boo
Radley’s stayed shut up in the house all this time.”